Org. De Financement | Engagements |
---|---|
Borrower/Recipient | 16.32 |
Global Environment Facility (GEF) | 17.00 |
P075035
Closed
Liping Jiang
N/A
6 septembre 2002
(à la date de présentation au Conseil)
15 avril 2004
22 septembre 2004
USD 33.32 millions
N/A
2004
USD 17.00 millions
C
15 janvier 2013
30 juin 2011
BANK APPROVED
Org. De Financement | Engagements |
---|---|
Borrower/Recipient | 16.32 |
Global Environment Facility (GEF) | 17.00 |
Type de produit/service | BIRD/IDA |
---|---|
Engagement BIRD | N/D |
Engagement IDA | N/D |
Engagement BIRD + IDA | N/D |
Instrument de prêt | |
---|---|
Élément don | 17.00 |
Coût total du projet** | 33.32 |
Name | Review | Date |
---|---|---|
Summary Global Objective Rating | Highly Satisfactory | 2011-06-20 |
Procurement | Satisfactory | 2011-06-20 |
Project Management | Satisfactory | 2011-06-20 |
Monitoring and Evaluation | Satisfactory | 2011-06-20 |
Overall | Low | 2011-06-20 |
Overall Safeguards Rating | Satisfactory | 2011-06-20 |
Counterpart Funding | Satisfactory | 2011-06-20 |
Financial Management | Satisfactory | 2011-06-20 |
Overall Implementation Progress (IP) | Satisfactory | 2011-06-20 |
Overall Safeguards Rating | Satisfactory | 2011-06-20 |
INDICATEUR | BILAN DE FIN D’EXÉCUTION ET DE RÉSULTATS: 12-27-2011 |
---|---|
Résultats | Highly Satisfactory |
Risques pour les résultats de développement | Negligible |
Performance de la Banque | Substantial |
Performance de l'emprunteur | Highly Satisfactory |
Performance de l’État | Highly Satisfactory |
Organisme d'exécution | Highly Satisfactory |
INDICATEUR | EXAMEN RFE: 05-13-2013 | RAPPORT D’ÉVALUATION RÉTROSPECTIVE DE PROJET: 06-19-2015 |
---|---|---|
Évaluation Des Résultats | Moderately Satisfactory | Satisfactory |
Risques Pour Les Résultats De Développement | Negligible To Low | Substantial |
Performance De La Banque | Satisfactory | Satisfactory |
Performance De L'emprunteur | Moderately Satisfactory | Satisfactory |
Performance De L’état | Moderately Satisfactory | Not Rated |
Organisme D'exécution | Moderately Satisfactory | Satisfactory |
Qualité Des Rfe | Satisfactory | Not Rated |
Qualité Du Suivi-évaluation | Modest | Substantial |
INDICATEUR | NIVEAU DE RÉFÉRENCE | EN COURS | OBJECTIF |
---|
INDICATEUR | NIVEAU DE RÉFÉRENCE | EN COURS | OBJECTIF |
---|
Substantial reduction of pollution loading and groundwater overdraft in the selected counties. | Valeur | For the 16 pilot counties: 1. COD:108,372 tons/ye | Substantial reduction in 2009 has been made: 1. C | Pollution loading to the rivers is reduced by 30% |
Date | 22 septembre 2004 | 17 décembre 2010 | 30 juin 2011 | |
Observation | The above baseline data were updated based on the final review of the historical data by MEP and MWR. | The above data were based on the M&E data for 2009. The data for 2010 was not available. | The targets were consistent with the PAD. |
Cooperation mechanisms between water departments and environment departments at central, provincial, municipal and county levels have been prepared, updated every year and implemented. | Valeur | No cooperation mechanisms were established and imp | The documents on cooperation mechanisms were prepa | Implementation of the cooperation mechanisms betwe |
Date | 22 septembre 2004 | 17 décembre 2010 | 30 juin 2011 | |
Observation |
16 IWEMPs for the selected 16 pilot counties, IWEMP for Tianjin, 2 Action Plans for Hai Basin and ZWN sub-basin were prepared and supported by 10 strategic studies, KM/ET and demonstration projects. | Valeur | No IWEMPs, Action Plans, Strategic Studies, KM/ET | IWEMPs, Action Plans, Strategic Studies, KM/ET, an | IWEMPs, Action Plans, Strategic Studies, KM/ET, an |
Date | 22 septembre 2004 | 17 décembre 2010 | 30 juin 2011 | |
Observation |
Tianjin Coastal Wastewater Management component including Dagu industrial pollution control, Hangu wastewater management with financial incentives is well implemented and produces good impacts. | Valeur | The waste water treatment in small towns was not s | Tianjin coastal waste water management component i | Impact of Dagu industrial pollution control was ac |
Date | 22 septembre 2004 | 17 décembre 2010 | 30 juin 2011 | |
Observation |