Org. De Financement | Engagements |
---|---|
IDA Credit | 28.15 |
P071407
Closed
W. Marie Sheppard
N/A
15 juin 2001
(à la date de présentation au Conseil)
29 juillet 2004
10 novembre 2004
USD 28.15 millions
N/A
2005
USD 28.15 millions
B
15 janvier 2013
30 novembre 2011
BANK APPROVED
Org. De Financement | Engagements |
---|---|
IDA Credit | 28.15 |
Type de produit/service | BIRD/IDA |
---|---|
Engagement BIRD | N/D |
Engagement IDA | 28.15 |
Engagement BIRD + IDA | 28.15 |
Instrument de prêt | |
---|---|
Élément don | N/D |
Coût total du projet** | 28.15 |
Name | Review | Date |
---|---|---|
Progress towards achievement of PDO | Moderately Unsatisfactory | 2011-10-29 |
Procurement | Moderately Satisfactory | 2011-10-29 |
Counterpart Funding | Moderately Satisfactory | 2011-10-29 |
Project Management | Satisfactory | 2011-10-29 |
Financial Management | Satisfactory | 2011-10-29 |
Monitoring and Evaluation | Moderately Satisfactory | 2011-10-29 |
Overall Implementation Progress (IP) | Moderately Satisfactory | 2011-10-29 |
INDICATEUR | BILAN DE FIN D’EXÉCUTION ET DE RÉSULTATS: 06-29-2012 |
---|---|
Résultats | Moderately Satisfactory |
Risques pour les résultats de développement | Substantial |
Performance de la Banque | Moderately Unsatisfactory |
Performance de l'emprunteur | Moderately Unsatisfactory |
Performance de l’État | Not Applicable |
Organisme d'exécution | Not Applicable |
INDICATEUR | EXAMEN RFE: 12-20-2012 | RAPPORT D’ÉVALUATION RÉTROSPECTIVE DE PROJET: |
---|---|---|
Évaluation Des Résultats | Moderately Unsatisfactory | N/a |
Risques Pour Les Résultats De Développement | Significant | N/a |
Performance De La Banque | Moderately Unsatisfactory | N/a |
Performance De L'emprunteur | Moderately Unsatisfactory | N/a |
Performance De L’état | Moderately Unsatisfactory | N/a |
Organisme D'exécution | Moderately Unsatisfactory | N/a |
Qualité Des Rfe | Satisfactory | N/a |
Qualité Du Suivi-évaluation | Modest | N/a |
INDICATEUR | NIVEAU DE RÉFÉRENCE | EN COURS | OBJECTIF |
---|
Average days to process tourism licenses issues at MTENR new one-stop-shop | Valeur | 90.00 | 90.00 | 60.00 |
Date | 25 juin 2004 | 5 août 2011 | 30 novembre 2011 | |
Observation | Progress has been made by GRZ including:1) Formal drafting of new Tourism & Hospitality Act that was based on internationalbestpractice and consultations with industry. 2) Construction of the One Stop Shop in Livingstone is ahead of schedule3) the OneStop Shop is now a joint initiative of MTENR and MCTI and will house a range of licensing authorities.While this represents solidprogress, the indicator can only be achieved after the THA is enacted. The Presidential election has delayed enactment, andtheMinistry of Justice advises that the proposed Act will go to Parliament in the first sitting of the new Government. However,this could betoo late for the SEED Project - which closes in November 2011.NOTE: New M&E Officer for project is updatingindicators values andthis information will be entered upon receipt. The above value is an estimate. |
Average time to process mining licenses applications | Valeur | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
Date | 3 janvier 2006 | 5 août 2011 | 30 novembre 2011 | |
Observation | See breakdown below | A similar situation exists with respect to the Mines & Minerals Act. Specifically, (i) The Mines & Minerals Draft Act wasrewritten based on intl experience and consultations were held. However, this draft will not be submitted to Parliament due to theelectioncycle (and concerns about repealing/replacing an Act in an election year). (ii) Cadastre is operating but not effective.There arewidespread concerns with independence, efficacy & financial viablity of cadastre and related governance issues.Theconcerns aboutthecadastre were discussed with GRZ and while some technical progress was made (e.g. hiring of a firm to update &improve the software)the other issues are of a political nature and given the election season, are unlikely to be addressed.NOTE:New M&E Officer for project is updating indicators values and this information will be entered upon receipt. | See breakdown below |
Unutilized licenses in the mining sector | Valeur | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
Date | 31 décembre 2004 | 5 août 2011 | 30 novembre 2011 | |
Observation | Not data available | We are awaiting a report from the Ministry of Mines on this indicator. | 50% reduction over baseline. Not data available |
Small-scale mining | Valeur | 30.00 | 30.00 | 15.00 |
Date | 3 janvier 2006 | 5 août 2011 | 30 novembre 2011 | |
Observation | Same as the above, as the Mines and Minerals Act and cadastre will determine the extent to which this goal will beachieved.NOTE:New M&E Officer for project is updating indicators values and this information will be entered upon receipt. Thecurrent value is an estimate. |
Large-scale mining | Valeur | 60.00 | 60.00 | 30.00 |
Date | 3 janvier 2006 | 5 août 2011 | 30 novembre 2011 | |
Observation | Same as aboveNote: The current value is an estimate pending data from the new M&E Officer |
INDICATEUR | NIVEAU DE RÉFÉRENCE | EN COURS | OBJECTIF |
---|
Management effectiveness score as measure using the WB/WWF tracking tool for MNP and KNP | Valeur | |||
Date | 31 décembre 2010 | 30 novembre 2011 | ||
Observation | Score disaggregated in sub indicators | Score disaggregated in sub indicators | Score disaggregated in sub indicators |
Reduction of the number of operating licences for tourism business issued by MTENR | Valeur | 5 | 5 | 1 |
Date | 30 novembre 2004 | 5 août 2011 | 30 novembre 2011 | |
Observation | It is impossible to change the number of licenses without changing the legislation, hence the focus, going forward, to helpGovernment create an enabling piece of tourism legislation and regulations. | Draft Tourism & Hospitality Act prepared and ready for submission to Cabinet then Parliament once new Government elected. TheDraft Act reduces the number of licenses to one.NOTE: New M&E Officer for project is updating indicators values and thisinformation will be entered upon receipt. |
Increase in revenue collection at Kitwe and :Livingstone mining bureau | Valeur | 0 | 0 | 90 |
Date | 31 décembre 2004 | 5 août 2011 | 25 novembre 2011 | |
Observation | We understand that there has been no increase in revenue collection. However, this is to be confirmed by the new M&Eofficer.NOTE: New M&E Officer for project is updating indicators values and this information will be entered upon receipt. |
Population of key wildlife in Kafue National Park | Valeur | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.00 |
Date | 30 septembre 2006 | 30 novembre 2011 | ||
Observation | Initial baseline was 2004 survey. But data were inconsistent. So 2006 survey is used as baseline. | Cannot be agregated. Measured 2008. Aerial survey only every two years | Aerial survey started on September 1, 2011. Data will be available by end of project. |
Pilot one-stop-shop licensing facility in Livinstone is functional | Valeur | No | No | Yes |
Date | 30 novembre 2004 | 5 août 2011 | 30 novembre 2011 | |
Observation | - Construction of the OSS almost complete.- GRZ decided to house multiple agencies in the OSS so as to streamline a range oflicenses.- OSS unlikely to be functioning prior to project close and mission informed that GRZ has committed to funding fittingout/utilities for OSS. |
Roads rehabilitated, Rural | Valeur | 0.00 | 17.00 | 17.00 |
Date | 30 novembre 2004 | 30 juin 2011 | 30 novembre 2011 | |
Observation | The infrastructure has been completed and there are concerns with respect to the maintenance of roads, street lights and MukuniPark. |
Park area covered by patrol | Valeur | 50.00 | 87.60 | 90.00 |
Date | 30 novembre 2004 | 31 décembre 2010 | 30 novembre 2011 | |
Observation |
National Mineral Development Policy and Strategy adopted | Valeur | No | No | Yes |
Date | 30 novembre 2004 | 5 août 2011 | 30 novembre 2011 | |
Observation | This has not been done. |
Revised legal and regulatory framework for mining enacted | Valeur | No | Yes | Yes |
Date | 30 novembre 2004 | 5 août 2011 | 30 novembre 2011 | |
Observation | The legal and regulatory framework that was enacted (two years ago) was counterproductive to the PDO. Hence, GRZ has prepared anew Act that is more enabling and represents international best practice. |
Central Mining Cadastre system installed, commissioned, and operational | Valeur | No | Yes | Yes |
Date | 30 novembre 2004 | 5 août 2011 | 30 novembre 2011 | |
Observation | The cadastre has been operating for two years. However, there are concerns about its efficacy as articulated in the independentdiagnosis and by key stakeholders. |
Elephants | Valeur | 4263.00 | 2250.00 | 6621.00 |
Date | 30 septembre 2006 | 31 décembre 2008 | 30 novembre 2011 | |
Observation |
Puku | Valeur | 9146.00 | 5700.00 | 12164.00 |
Date | 30 septembre 2006 | 31 décembre 2008 | 30 novembre 2011 | |
Observation |
Buffalo | Valeur | 4985.00 | 6300.00 | 15156.00 |
Date | 30 septembre 2006 | 31 décembre 2008 | 30 novembre 2011 | |
Observation |
Red Lechwe | Valeur | 5858.00 | 5500.00 | 9324.00 |
Date | 30 septembre 2006 | 31 décembre 2009 | 30 novembre 2011 | |
Observation |
Lodges accessible all weather | Valeur | 27.00 | 60.00 | 0.00 |
Date | 30 novembre 2004 | 30 décembre 2010 | ||
Observation |
Patrol deployement area accessible all weather | Valeur | 74.00 | 75.00 | 90.00 |
Date | 30 novembre 2004 | 30 novembre 2011 | ||
Observation |
Mosi oa Tunya National Park | Valeur | 46 | 50 | 50 |
Date | 31 décembre 2004 | 31 décembre 2010 | 30 novembre 2011 | |
Observation |
Kafue National Park | Valeur | 41 | 61 | 64 |
Date | 31 décembre 2004 | 31 décembre 2010 | 30 novembre 2011 | |
Observation |